Company Regulations vs. Employment Agreements: Navigating Conflicts and Compliance

The interplay between employment agreements, company regulations, and collective labor agreements often creates legal uncertainty for employers in Indonesia. Understanding their hierarchy and applying the principle of favor laboris, which prioritizes provisions most favorable to employees, is essential to ensure compliance and prevent disputes. Practical tips such as harmonizing documents, monitoring legal changes, and seeking legal advice can help employers manage risks effectively. This article provides concise guidance for navigating these complexities and aligning employment instruments to support legal clarity and industrial harmony.

In Indonesia, the employment relationship between employers and their employees is governed by a framework comprising employment agreements, company regulations, and where applicable, collective labor agreements. Each of these instruments serves a distinct legal function; however, conflicts among them are not uncommon. Overlapping provisions or inconsistent terms can create ambiguity and, in some cases, lead to legal disputes.

This article examines the interplay among these regulatory instruments, outlines the legal hierarchy under Indonesian employment law, and offers practical guidance for employers to maintain compliance and reduce risk. In a legal landscape where clarity is key, understanding how to navigate these instruments is not just advisable; it is essential.

Understanding the Legal Instruments

For the purposes of this article, the term “legal instruments” refers specifically to the core regulatory documents recognized under the Manpower Law (Law No. 13 of 2003 on Manpower, including its amendments), each playing a vital role in shaping the employment relationship:

Employment Agreement (Perjanjian Kerja): A legally binding contract between an individual employee and the employer, outlining the specific terms and conditions of employment, including duties, compensation, benefits, and termination procedures. This agreement forms the cornerstone of the individual employment relationship.
Company Regulations (Peraturan Perusahaan): A comprehensive set of internal rules unilaterally prepared by the employer, aimed at governing internal policies, working conditions, disciplinary measures, and other operational aspects. These regulations apply uniformly to all employees and must be registered with the local manpower office.
Collective Labor Agreement (Perjanjian Kerja Bersama or PKB): A negotiated agreement between the employer and a registered labor union, binding on both parties and applicable to all union members. Where applicable, a PKB overrides company regulations in the event of conflicting provisions.

Depending on the company structure and workforce composition, one or more of these instruments may coexist. Understanding their interplay and determining which instrument prevails in conflicts are critical for sound human resource governance.

Hierarchy of Employment Legal Instruments

While the Manpower Law and its implementing regulations do not expressly codify the hierarchy of these instruments in a single provision, a general framework can be inferred from statutory interpretations and prevailing practice. The accepted order of precedence is as follows:

Statutory Laws and Government Regulations: At the top are formal laws and regulations, including the Manpower Law, which provide the foundational rules for employment relationships in Indonesia.
Collective Labor Agreement (PKB): Where applicable, a PKB governs the terms of employment for union members and overrides any conflicting provisions in company regulations. It reflects a balanced outcome of negotiations between the employer and its employees.
Company Regulations: These apply to all employees not covered by a PKB and serve as the default internal policy framework. Company regulations must be approved by the relevant manpower authority.
Employment Agreements: These apply on a one-to-one basis between an employer and an employee. While they must conform to the above instruments, they may prevail insofar as they provide terms more favorable to the employee.

One of the cornerstones of Indonesian employment law is the principle of favor laboris, which requires that, in the event of conflicting provisions, the one most beneficial to the employee shall take precedence. This principle is expressly recognized in the elucidation of Article 61 paragraph (5) of the Manpower Law, underscoring the law’s protective stance toward employees.

As is often the case in employment law, the devil is in the details. Misalignment between employment agreements, company regulations, and collective labor agreements can open the door to legal liability. Thus, a proactive and harmonized approach to document governance is essential, not only for compliance but also for maintaining clarity and industrial peace.

Practical Tips for Employers

To ensure consistency and minimize the risk of legal disputes, employers are encouraged to observe the following best practices:

Review and Harmonize Employment Instruments: Conduct a periodic and comprehensive review of all employment-related documents to ensure alignment with one another and compliance with applicable laws.
Monitor Legal Developments: Employment law and regulations are subject to change. Stay informed and update internal documentation accordingly to remain compliant with current standards.
Engage Legal Counsel: Where uncertainties arise, particularly involving union negotiations or regulatory interpretation, seek the advice of qualified legal professionals to ensure enforceability and reduce legal risk.

Conclusion

The interplay between employment agreements, company regulations, and collective labor agreements can be complex, especially when applied simultaneously. However, by understanding the legal hierarchy and prioritizing the most favorable terms for employees, companies can navigate these complexities more effectively and remain compliant.

Ultimately, aligning employment instruments not only prevents disputes but also promotes trust, transparency, and stronger industrial relations. As with most legal risk matters, an ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure—a proactive approach today can safeguard your organization tomorrow.

***

About ADCO Law:

ADCO Law is a law firm that offers clients a wide range of integrated legal services, including commercial transactions and corporate disputes in a variety of industry sectors. Over the course of more than a decade, we have grown to understand our clients’ industries and businesses as well as the regulatory aspects. In dealing with business dynamics, we provide comprehensive, solid legal advice and solutions to minimize legal and business risks.

From Upstream to Downstream, We Understand Your Industry. In complex transactions and certain cases, we actively engage with financial, tax, and environmental specialists, accountants, and law firms from various jurisdictions to add value to our clients. Our strong relationships with Government agencies, regulators, associations, and industry stakeholders ensure that our firm has a holistic view of legal matters.

ADCO Law is a Proud Member of the Alliott Global Alliance (AGA) in Indonesia. Founded in 1979, AGA is one of the largest and fastest-growing global multidisciplinary alliances, with 215 member firms in 95 countries. As a law firm, we also believe in regeneration. To stay abreast of business changes and stay relevant, our formation of lawyers is comprised of the top graduates from Indonesian and international law schools.

Contact our Business Development team for further information:

Alvin Mediadi, Business Development Manager, Indonesia

alvin@adcolaw.com